Take the 2-minute tour ×
Martial Arts Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for students and teachers of all martial arts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I like full contact hard body sparring. I'm not much of a fan of a lot of katas, since I've been through enough of that in TKD. However, I wouldn't mind some kata. I'm also not a fan of karate joint locks. If I wanted to emphasize that, I'd take BJJ or Judo.

Taking these stipulations into account, would I prefer Shotokan or Kyokushin? Which one would be a better fit for me?

share|improve this question
1  
why not kicboxing? muay thai? mma? –  Keith Nicholas Nov 27 '13 at 2:22
add comment

4 Answers

I like the fact that Masutatsu Oyama, the fonder of Kyukushin, fought 50 bulls (or so the rumour goes).

I would pick Kyukushin as the better style because its mixture of Japanese straight and powerful attacks and Chinese "iron ball at the end of a chain" techniques make it much more well-rounded. Oyama was a karateka first, before studying Chinese martial arts and you can actually see the progression when you look at the difference between the lower Kata's and the higher. The lower Kata's are more traditionally Japanese and probably look quite similar to Shotokan or Goju-ryu kata, while the higher grades' Kata's have a more flowing, circular feel as one often sees in the Chinese flavours.

share|improve this answer
    
All the Oyama biographies report that he learned Chinese first, as a boy working on a farm, before learning Shotokan later. The fact that lower-grade Kyokushin kata are more rigid is, I would contend, a pedagogical choice. I would note that orthodox Shotokan shares that progression towards more circular, flowing kata at the advanced levels. –  Dave Liepmann Nov 26 '13 at 12:50
    
That's what you get when trying to quote from memory something you learned more than a decade ago. –  Juann Strauss Nov 27 '13 at 14:13
1  
Happens to the best of us. –  Dave Liepmann Nov 27 '13 at 14:18
add comment

If your preference is full-contact sparring, then Shotokan sucks and Kyokushin rocks, because Shotokan doesn't have full-contact sparring and Kyokushin does.

share|improve this answer
add comment

Kyokushin sparring rules are almost always continuous and full-contact, with nearly the entire body as a target except that one cannot punch to the head. I've heard that some Kyokushin schools and offshoots incorporate boxing gloves and face punching. Generally, "full contact" sparring means "medium to hard contact" in class, titrated to one's partner's ability to take punishment, and "full contact" reserved mostly for competition. One scores by knocking the opponent down. Leg kicks are very, very common.

Shotokan kumite is generally light-contact (or "controlled" contact), stops or resets after a successful strike, and usually does not allow leg kicks. Sweeps, however, are generally permitted. One scores by landing a clean blow. As collected on E-budo:

  • Attacking areas are limited to the face, head, neck, abdomen, side of the body, chest and back (excluding the shoulders).
  • Skin touch control must be exercised with any techniques to the face, head or neck.

Note that "excessive contact" is prohibited in Shotokan, as are "repeated direct attacks to the arm or legs". This is dramatically different from Kyokushin.

Both styles wear the funny Asian pajamas, do the krotty dances, and have a lot of the bowing stuff. Whether they do joint locks is dependent on the individual teacher, but it probably won't be a major part of the syllabus in either style.

share|improve this answer
    
"krotty dances" sounds snide to me. –  Trevoke Nov 27 '13 at 15:04
    
@Trevoke Maybe that's because it's paired with "funny Asian pajamas" and is intended to critique the practice a little. The latter part of the term is not without prior art: see Peter Urban's classic The Karate Dojo. –  Dave Liepmann Nov 27 '13 at 15:09
    
Well, it reminds me of the scene at the end of V for Vendetta, really. "You've got nothing. Nothing but your bloody knives and your fancy karate gimmicks." The pyjama bit is something I hear a lot. It's the intentional misspelling that irked me. Dancing and martial arts have a lot in common. –  Trevoke Nov 27 '13 at 18:14
add comment

Kyokushin has a lot more focus on hard sparring. As Dave writes in his answer, for tournaments, Shotokan fights are usually stopped after a successful technique lands (much like fencing), while Kyokushin fights are only stopped when the technique is effective (i.e. the opponent is either knocked out or knocked down).

Knockouts are common in Kyokushin, while excessive contact is penalized in point karate.

As for the kata, I believe Kyokushin and Shotokan share many kata, although their interpretation may be slightly different. However, depending on the school, it might be possible to focus almost entirely on fighting and less on kata (or vice versa) once you reach a certain level.

If you enjoy hard sparring but not the kata, you might consider one of the Kyokushin offshoots.

Ashihara Karate is a direct offshoot of Kyokushin, and shares the same view on hard sparring (knockdown karate). However, their view on kata is different. While traditional kata are very stylistic, the Ashihara kata are more practical. The intention is, that the individual combinations can be transferred directly into fighting.

Example of Ashihara kata

Enshin Karate is in turn an offshoot of Ashihara, and is very, very similar. The only difference is that they have fewer kata.

There are other styles as well: Daido Juku/Kudo, Seidokaikan (parent organization of K1) and several more. Most of them are descendants of Kyokushin or Ashihara, and are grouped together as "Knockdown Karate".

share|improve this answer
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.