Take the 2-minute tour ×
Martial Arts Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for students and teachers of all martial arts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

What are the general tactics of Krav Maga as opposed to Systema?

For instance, the tactics of Silat are to hurt the other person so badly they can't hurt back. Another example would be that the tactics of boxing would be to knock out the other person first using only punches. So, as far as I know, the goal of Systema and Krav Maga are both to do anything you can to defeat your attacker because they are serious about self defense. Does that mean that Krav Maga and Systema are strategical identical? Does Krav use strategies that Systema doesn't? Does Systema use any strategies that Krav doesn't? Is there a difference or do they generally work the same way?

share|improve this question
2  
It's a little difficult to tell what exactly you are asking here. System and Krav Maga have some significant dissimilarities and different histories, and so I'm not sure how to narrow down a good answer from the question. –  David H. Clements Jun 2 at 15:04
    
Oh, so then are they just completely different? Is there an advantage to doing one as opposed to the other? I have to rephrase this question. Thank you. –  user2932 Jun 2 at 18:13
4  
I think this is a fantastic question. It's very specific, on-topic, and absolutely answerable. I don't know the answer but I edited the question to be more focused. –  Dave Liepmann Jun 2 at 18:39
2  
The edited question is much better. –  Sardathrion Jun 3 at 7:39
    
Hm, I had some years doing Krav now and my goal never was to defeat the attacker but to get away with as less injuries as possible without being further persued... –  Fildor Jul 10 at 20:27

1 Answer 1

At first glance Krav Maga and Systema seem to be very similar in that they are both very unconventional, no-rules, practical self-defence, martial arts (although Krav isn't technically a martial art) which are no holds barred and generally formless.

However...

Krav Maga is basically a very raw, dangerous situation survival system (including avoidance and escape) which builds upon your natural instincts and taught in a very short space of time. Therefore it is highly stress tested. It relies on the fact that fear will set in in order to use your natural responses and turn them into functional movements to your advantage. It relies heavily on shock and awe in that defence and attack should be simultaneous where possible to capitalise on the opponents shock value.

Systema is -in many ways- the exact opposite, it is a system which teaches over a much longer period of time how to control your fear/anger/pity and teaches relaxation (through breathing/stretching) in stressful situations so that attacks on your person are less effective, better recovered from and the pressure points, levers and momentum of attackers can be manipulated to your advantage using the clarity of mind gained from your training.

In Summary

So in effect Krav Maga is taught fast and turns your weaknesses into strengths so your defence/attack becomes like a reflex just when you need it while Systema is a methodology that needs to be learned and seeks to remove you of those weaknesses so that your defense/attacks can be more effective.

Also

Another martial art, similar and somewhere between these is the Keysi Fighting Method (KFM) -developed for street fighting- but that has some actual forms that have to be learned such as the very distinctive El Pensador that the Christian Bale Batman uses ;).

share|improve this answer
    
I knew about KFM and how Batman uses it in the Dark Knight trilogy. But I would also wonder what the difference is then between the above and KFM. –  user2932 Jul 18 at 21:54
    
KFM is alot more like Krav Maga but it makes heavy use of El Pensador guard (much like the Rhino Krav post) and concentrates a much larger chunk of it's time to dealing with multiple opponents and ground based fighting. It doesn't deal with survival (avoidance and get away) as much as Krav However. There are also no weapons. –  Ross Drew Jul 19 at 15:20

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.