10,296 reputation
1849
bio website
location
age
visits member for 2 years, 8 months
seen 5 hours ago

Judo ikkyu (brown belt)

BJJ 4-stripe white belt

2nd dan Isshinryu, former instructor, don't believe in it anymore

negligible experience with boxing and muay Thai


Oct
1
comment What are the applications and principles of this particular seven-star mantis stance?
@Ho-ShengHsiao No. Making up applications on whimsy is not how people who received actual transmission practice.
Oct
1
comment What are the applications and principles of this particular seven-star mantis stance?
-1 for trying to reverse engineer the form. That misguided practice is the source of a huge quantity of poor martial skills.
Oct
1
comment How long should it take to gain fighting proficiency in tai chi?
@DaveNewton He's making the point that taiji is a physical skill. Like any physical skill, it should be practiced in a manner as close as possible to its application.
Oct
1
comment How long should it take to gain fighting proficiency in tai chi?
@DaveNewton Well, I suggest taking that up with the tai chi coaches who use that analogy. The guy is a CMA lineage holder and multiple-time champion in competitions of the gentle art.
Oct
1
comment For a total beginner, is tai chi a good start?
People who have the ability to train more vigorously than forms-only tai chi should generally do so. People who cannot (such as the detrained elderly) get a lot more benefit out of low-grade exercise such as tai chi as it is generally practiced in the USA.
Sep
27
comment Dropping weight before a MMA fight
@SimonPeterChappell The issue is that you don't show up for a tournament most times. MMA bouts are generally 1-fight affairs, with a great deal of preparation going into them, and the results put in your permanent record. So being outweighed even by a few pounds is a bigger deal than in local judo competition.
Sep
27
comment How dangerous is it to choke someone unconscious or to be choked unconscious?
@MarkC.Wallace Quite dangerous how?
Sep
27
comment How dangerous is it to choke someone unconscious or to be choked unconscious?
-1, the first paragraph is unsupported by anecdote or data. Cutting off cerebral blood flow via blood choke is exactly what millions of judo, BJJ, SAMBO, and submission grappling exponents practice extensively every day without the ill effects you claim.
Sep
27
comment Exercises to help “getting lower” when performing Jiu-Jitsu throws
This is almost an exact duplicate of this question.
Sep
27
comment Best weight lifting exercise to develop a Wing Chun chain punch
-1 The bench press increases explosive strength by increasing strength. (Explosive strength is a function of strength.)
Sep
27
comment What is the best martial art for reducing back pain and stress while increasing my fitness?
Anyway, great answer, David.
Sep
24
comment how to overcome “freeze”?
Yeah, just more practice.
Sep
19
comment Drills for teaching range analysis
I downvoted because I've done this drill and found it unproductive. It seems to me to be more of a karate mind game than a useful exercise in learning distancing. It lacks footwork, live experimentation with the range, and agency on the part of the student. The last sentence also indicates a troubling lack of meaningful integration of the drill with sparring or more robust live drilling. It is similar to a useful drill, but the one-sidedness of this version, combined with a lack of movement on the part of the student, makes it unproductive.
Sep
13
comment Was Goju-ryu developed specifically for use by the Japanese navy?
@Sepala To be clear, my statement doesn't at all mean that Goju is ideally suited for close-quarters combat. (I'd trust judo or Greco-Roman wrestling more.) I'm just saying that goju could be better than a style that trains at long range exclusively.
Sep
11
comment How do I improve my jumping technique for jumping maneuvers?
You might get more comprehensive results in fitness.SE. Jumping is a fairly rich topic in sports science.
Sep
3
comment Avoiding breath lockups
How much of a beginner?
Aug
30
comment What are good martial arts for aging bodies?
You describe two styles, but I see virtually no description of why one would practice these instead of anything else.
Aug
29
comment What are some options for escaping full mount in BJJ?
Excellent point in the 2nd paragraph.
Aug
28
comment Choosing the right one for self-defense purpose?
@DavidH.Clements What is keeping this question closed?
Aug
27
comment How do I increase my wrist strength for punching?
@stslavik Didn't see the request for PP link till just now -- it's this one: encrypted.google.com/… aka aasgaardco.com/store/…