meta user
network profile
| bio | website | budo.markcwallace.net |
|---|---|---|
| location | United States | |
| age | 50 | |
| visits | member for | 1 year |
| seen | 15 hours ago | |
| stats | profile views | 2 |
I'm currently studying Tomiki Aikido under Dr. Yoji Kondo, although I started in Yoshinkan aikido under Helton-Sensei. I'm also studying Taiji under D. Gilmer at StillwaterTaichi I'm informally studying jo and bokken.
|
15h |
comment |
What makes this seated Daito-ryu technique work? Probably - that is my understanding. My only reservation is it makes it sound like I know what I'm talking about, and that's always dangerous. |
|
15h |
comment |
What makes this seated Daito-ryu technique work? I'm not sure whether you replied before I finished my edit. These are koryu, which means they aren't done to be pragmatic. (The pragmatic stuff is in the junana hon kata).(overstating for simplicity). Most koryu techniques make... contrived assumptions about ukes attack and intent, and if the uke isn't trained to actually follow that script, you get the phenomenon you described "jump for sensei". Koryu is like a sonnet. Sonnets are written within narrow, artificial guidelines, not for pure pragmatism. Koryu are designed to teach concepts, not pragmatism. (IMHO) |
|
15h |
revised |
What makes this seated Daito-ryu technique work? added 863 characters in body |
|
16h |
comment |
What makes this seated Daito-ryu technique work? Could you give us a time mark on the video? You said "a few seconds" but the video is 10 minutes long. |
|
16h |
comment |
What makes this seated Daito-ryu technique work? Upvoting @DaveLiepmann's question, because I think it is insightful. This is an interesting discussion because we're polarized, and I appreciate the effort to narrow the discussion to a very pragmatic, answerable question. |
|
16h |
comment |
What makes this seated Daito-ryu technique work? If nage turns wrists inward and upwards, then if uke unlocks the elbows, uke is unable to exert any force on nage. To unlock the elbows, uke has to disengage from nage, which nullifies the attack. (The goal is to nullify the attack, not to complete the throw.) I'm struggling to write that more clearly - I'm not sure that explanation passes muster. I can no longer get into seiza, but perhaps I can persuade a classmate to work with it this weekend, and perhaps I'll find a clearer way to explain it. |
|
23h |
answered | What makes this seated Daito-ryu technique work? |
|
2d |
reviewed | Reviewed Why drop the bokken vertical prior to a downstroke? |
|
May 20 |
reviewed | Reviewed Martial art for a complete newbie - can i learn on my own? |
|
May 17 |
awarded | Yearling |
|
May 8 |
reviewed | Excellent What is Fa-jin? |
|
May 8 |
reviewed | Needs Improvement Measuring the foot when buying Tabi (and giving the size using the japanese convention) |
|
May 8 |
reviewed | Satisfactory Training while exhausted |
|
May 8 |
reviewed | Satisfactory Mawashi Gheri Vs Dollyo Chagi |
|
May 8 |
reviewed | Excellent What can i practice to remove tension from my movements |
|
May 8 |
reviewed | Satisfactory Impact of being smaller(shorter arms) and how to overcome this |
|
May 8 |
reviewed | Satisfactory Are there any benefits to Sitting Seiza? |
|
May 8 |
reviewed | No Action Needed Designs for a Board Breaker / Board Holder? |
|
May 7 |
reviewed | No Action Needed What are the possible signs some has lost consciousness when being choked? |
|
May 6 |
revised |
How to adapt kote hineri against a larger opponent? added 204 characters in body; edited title |
