1,880 reputation
416
bio website
location Arizona
age
visits member for 2 years, 6 months
seen 2 hours ago

Dec
17
comment Martial art without exam and secrets
Hardly an expansive, explanatory answer. Should be a comment unless you can flesh it out some.
Dec
15
comment Martial art without exam and secrets
If you have someone that teaches you and "holds back" because they think you might beat them someday, that person should not be an instructor. The primary goal for ANY instructor, and a great compliment to the instructor is when the student can outperform them.
Dec
12
comment What is the name of this style of Karate (maybe?)?
@KeithNicholas - The internet has different standards than most SE sites.
Dec
12
comment What is the name of this style of Karate (maybe?)?
I realize that it is tongue in cheek, but as evidenced, a martial arts beginner may not know that you are mocking the style.
Dec
11
comment What is the name of the traditional taekwondo black belt bo form?
Is it possible that the form is named different? The only "chumbi" form I found was an introductory one by Westerfield TKD club, but a few that suggested it was a misspelling of "choon be", or the ready command.
Dec
11
comment What is the name of the traditional taekwondo black belt bo form?
As Andy Jeffries states, Kukkiwon does not recognize any official weapons forms. ATA has 3 different jangh bong forms, short range, long range and windstaff. I know a WTF school locally that has two different staff forms, which is different than the WTF school I attended in Nevada.
Dec
10
comment What are the belt colors of Tae Kwon Do in order?
Got it. And yes, a lot of federations allow Dan ranks to promote to a dan rank two below them. (3rd to 1st, 4th to 2nd, etc.), with high ranks (4+) needing a testing panel.
Dec
9
comment What are the belt colors of Tae Kwon Do in order?
Ah, cheers! I missed that when I was reading through yesterday.
Dec
8
comment What are the belt colors of Tae Kwon Do in order?
You talk about Dan rankings, they are not color belts. And you seem to treat the Kukkiwon as the sole arbiter of belts in TKD, which is far from the case.
Dec
8
comment What are the belt colors of Tae Kwon Do in order?
You left out poom ranks, as well as that not all TKD associations recognize 4th dan as Master, some are higher.
Dec
8
comment What are the belt colors of Tae Kwon Do in order?
I don't believe you have to be a 4th degree to conduct a colored belt test. You do (or have to bring in people) for dan testings, but I believe for colored belts you can be under 4th dan and still conduct the testing.
Dec
8
comment What are the belt colors of Tae Kwon Do in order?
@SeanDuggan - Some of it is marketing, but if you look at the meaning for each belt, it fits in. ATA compares the colored belt levels to the growth of a pine tree (Songahm, the ATA style, means pine tree and rock). Camouflage is the first level where light contact sparring (as opposed to one steps) is introduced, and the accompanying belt meaning is "The sapling is hidden among the taller pines and must new fight its way upward". Agreed, most belt colors are arbitrary anyway. The old adage about a black belt being a really dirty white belt doesn't account for orange, blue, purple, etc. :p
Dec
8
comment When are the new WTF competition rules going to happen?
+1. Add to this that WTF is not about to risk upsetting the powers that be in the Olympic committee. If you take away the Olympics, the WTF becomes just another martial art. There were already concerns about the number of knockouts/injuries in Olympic TKD bouts, I VERY much doubt that they would introduce higher levels of potential injury.
Dec
8
comment When are the new WTF competition rules going to happen?
While there are some talented martial artists on bullshido, take some of what they say/do with a grain of salt. Many there are of the opinion that if you don't sit on your opponent mashing his face into the pavement, your martial art isn't worth it.
Nov
25
comment Taekwondo Block Bunkai Vs. Shotokan Block Bunkai
ATA. Some of our strikes do wrap as you mention, but the blocks aren't quite as emphasized as the picture you show (With an atrocious front stance btw), and many do chamber out in front. I started in Shotokan originally, and I had a much easier time adapting to arm/hand techniques than I did to stance differences.
Nov
25
comment Taekwondo Block Bunkai Vs. Shotokan Block Bunkai
You can also consider that many styles teach overemphasized chambers to emphasize it, as many many students doesn't do things as far/tight/extended as they think they do.
Nov
25
comment Taekwondo Block Bunkai Vs. Shotokan Block Bunkai
Also consider that you have chosen two separate blocks, rather than comparing the same block between styles. In my variant of TKD, my low block chamber has my blocking fist on my opposite shoulder, with my block elbow pointing out and down from my body, not wrapped around my neck. Our inner forearm block (Which matches the middle block in your video) chambers in front in the same fashion as the video.
Nov
20
comment Reducing Soreness?
Yes, I'm aware of that effect, and I blame that for assisting with my achilles rupture. I guess what I was having trouble with was the "stuck" nomenclature, as they don't really stick, they readjust their internal thermostat so to speak.
Nov
20
comment Reducing Soreness?
Sigh.... Lactic acid is a fuel, and is NOT responsible for DOMS. I'd also be interested in your reference for muscle spindles getting "stuck" in shortened positions.
Nov
12
comment Between Kyokushin and Shotokan, which focuses more on hard sparring and less on kata?
@Trevoke - You need to lighten up. "krotty" has been an inside joke since I've been in martial arts (30 years now), as has fancy pajamas.