245 reputation
27
bio website
location
age
visits member for 2 years, 8 months
seen Sep 19 at 15:06

Jun
5
comment When doing Aikido practice why should the attacker adapt to the defender?
@tacone easier for who?
Jun
2
comment What methods are effective for increasing co-ordination on dual handed techniques?
You are right. Anyway, I read your answer again and it is actually very good. I only commented the coordination part in my previous comment.
May
30
comment What methods are effective for increasing co-ordination on dual handed techniques?
Good answer, but perhaps you should add how to think of it as one stick: just realize that when one stick hits, the other goes backward, and then focus on this "scissor" move. It is much easier to focus on this than to think about each hand separately. Helped me in the "heaven and earth" drill.
May
30
comment How can I practice shooting for a combat situation?
Paintball ....?
May
30
comment What methods are effective for increasing co-ordination on dual handed techniques?
I don't think this answer is of any use for double stick. The question was how to coordinate both hands at once, which is best answered by Trevoke.
May
17
comment Does Krav Maga have any roots of Aikido?
@Matt, I see your point, but how can you describe 5 min video full of techniques? That would take few hours to describe, thousands of words, and who would ever read it? I'm afraid there's no way to answer this question but to watch the video.
May
13
comment What characteristics should I look for in a sensei?
I don't agree to any of your points in "Martial Science" block. Many great masters would not pass this. Watch Karate Kid to get an example :) (BTW, martial art is not a science.)
Apr
17
comment kicked in the sternum - tips on healing, time frame? any lingering danger?
+1 for "It will take substantially less time to heal if you just let it heal.". To finish your rhyme: but it is not what the op wants to hear :-)
Feb
18
comment What's the real difference between Ikkyo omote and Nikkyo omote?
our sensei and other instructors also told us that ikkyo and nikkyo are different directions. I never understood this. They started with ikkyo omote and told us that there are 4 directions to continue to: ikkyo, nikyo, sankyo (towards the opponent), and to 4th was jonkyo ?? Don't remember. I never really understood this - and so for me personally it temporarily fell to the category of "esoteric crap"... as @tacone mentioned :)
Feb
17
comment What martial art should I start with?
Great answer! Expressive, not cluttered with thousand words, going straigt to the problem!
Feb
17
comment What's the real difference between Ikkyo omote and Nikkyo omote?
+1 for the esoteric stuff :-))) Yes, many aikidokas look like that :-)
Feb
16
comment Wing chun modification with only palm heel strikes?
@Trevoke, thanks. Sounds like "learning wing chun" blocks one's fighting progress :) (at least in those first 5 years)
Feb
16
comment Wing chun modification with only palm heel strikes?
Thanks @Trevoke - and what you think about Wing Chun and being combat-ready? In your classification, is it more like "martial art" (5-10yrs) or more like Krav Maga (months)?
Feb
16
comment Wing chun modification with only palm heel strikes?
@Trevoke, you mean that Krav Maga is much more effective than any martial art? I thought Wing Chun can be really effective.
Feb
1
comment Is practising techniques on both the left and right sides beneficial or detrimental to martial development?
@DavidH.Clements, this is not valid in aikido because jo is much longer than bokken (I think 130-140cm) and you train both sides equaly. So in aikido it really doesn't make much sense, it's probably only a tradition.
Feb
1
comment How to select the right Aikido dojo
more general question here. Mat, I already wrote my proposal in quotes, and your new one is much better.
Feb
1
comment When moving to a new city, what considerations need to be taken into account finding a new teacher?
similar answer here martialarts.stackexchange.com/a/97/93.
Feb
1
comment Wing chun modification with only palm heel strikes?
Yes it works for novices, and that's the plus - it is something effective and natural, that works from the beginning, not only after 3-4 years of training. IMHO the idea of wing chun is to be efective. Fixing punching habits would lower my natural efectivity for at least a year or two.
Feb
1
comment Wing chun modification with only palm heel strikes?
@slugster, your comment is more emotional, compared to rational explanation of the CQC instructor. And it's not only him, many other instructors recommend to use palm heels for the same reason. Tradition in martial arts sometimes wins over reason and logic, I know. That's why I'm asking.
Feb
1
comment Wing chun modification with only palm heel strikes?
well, but wing-chun doesn't use chain palm- heel strikes, or does it? I've only seen chain punch