5

I'm currently going to a gym where one trainer knows kick boxing. I told him that i want to learn. He told me that he will teach me without punching bag and that he also learned without them. That sounds bit suspicious to me.

Is it possible to do so?

  • 3
    It's possible to learn kickboxing without a punching bag, you'll just be missing a training tool. It wouldn't be possible to learn without a training partner. Maybe a better question is: is someone who doesn't have access to a punching bag likely to be qualified to teach kickboxing? And why is he choosing to teach you without a punching bag? Isn't there one at the gym? – The Wudang Kid May 12 '15 at 11:48
  • Welcome to the site. I edited your question to remove some unnecessary information and clean it up a little. Let me know if this has changed what you wanted answered. – Sardathrion - Reinstate Monica May 12 '15 at 12:53
  • 1
    Some of the more basic movements are often trained without a punching bag to develop some proper form. After you have some experience throwing punches around it is likely you would be encouraged to use other training tools like hand pads or a punching bag. If this trainer doesn't eventually move towards another form of training you will want to consider going else where, but you could develop some basic skills without one. – Cayce K May 13 '15 at 0:53
  • hello @CayceK can you please how can i develop basic skills without any trainer! actually i don't have much knowledge of foot drills and punching techniques or angle that how to through proper punches?! do you know any website or have any material that help me out ?? thanks in advance (^_^) – DexJ May 13 '15 at 13:09
4

Since you're wanting more information I'm going to post an answer to try and help you move forward with your training and your goals. I'm going to have to assume you have no prior training in any martial art and would be considered a novice in your training.

This answer will 100% reference Dave Liepmann's excellent answer.

The first and most important part is don't try to do it on your own. There is a reason all martial arts developed in groups. As a developing student you will learn many of the rights and wrongs from a skilled and informed trainer. Without one you will struggle, develop bad habits, and most likely become disheartened. You have an opportunity to learn from someone and I recommend giving it a shot. If the trainer you are working with does not seem to provide any valuable training effort or seems like he/she does not have much confidence I would not move forward with their services.

The other part of Liepmann's answer is there are other routes. Train! Train any skill that gets you in shape. Focus not on punching, kicking, or martial arts in general. Just get in shape and be confident in yourself. Continue to look for a trainer until you find your right fit, but until then develop other skills that you will inevitably need in your advancement.

Lastly, I sadly do not have any online resources. Though they could be there and may work for some I just never thought they were worth it. I had an in house "dojo" experience. I spent most my life being told my mistakes and then passing on my learnings to students. The most important part of that experience is having some one right there constructively telling me to do X when I thought I was doing X, but in fact doing Y. When you get a chance to experience that you will not want to watch a DVD or YouTube video.

I will give one thing for a proper punch that I feel is the most important.

Take your arm and lift in front of you. Point your index finger to the center of the monitor. At this point your arm should be straight and your finger pointed directly to center of monitor. Now close your index finger so that you make a fist. (Touch base... Your fist should be closed with your thumb OVER your index and middle fingers) Continue to imagine you're pointing your finger at the monitor.

If you notice in doing so your now closed index and middle fingers are the forward most knuckles. A proper punch will directly hit an object with those two knuckles almost exclusively. If you now try to point ANY other direction other than at your target (center of the monitor) you will quickly see what an incorrect punch looks like.

The reason you punch like this is because the way your hand is designed you have the full support by the bones in your arm to structure around protecting those knuckles from impact. Sadly the rest of your hand does not have that structure and will likely crumble even on a minimal hit. Save yourself the pain and time and practice pointing correctly and when you get a trainer have them verify and build on what I have told you. Even if they describe it differently.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.