5

Is there a method of sword fighting where one uses two handed techniques with a basket-hilted sword? I've heard that this happened, just not where, when, and what the technique was called.

2

Historically speaking, there wouldn't be much overlap between the us of the half-swording technique and the advent of the basket-hilted sword. Half-swording was typically used with a longsword by heavily armored combatants. The basket-hilt arose once technology had advanced to the point that heavy armor began to fall out of favor. The basket-hilt itself being a design to protect the unguantleted hand. Against the lightly armored soldiers of the day a basket-hilted blade would not require a technique like half-swording, but there may have been the odd exception (perhaps some twit who refused to retire his Maximillian-style fluted plate).

3
  • As you say, it'd have been a well established technique with longswords long before the time basket hilts became common. Breastplates weren't uncommon with mounted troops in particular, right up till the 19th century.If you're up close in a press, or just any time you needed better leverage. Mar 3 '16 at 10:23
  • Zen, I agree with you. My sense of half swording is that it has the most utility in the steel gauntlet era, and basket hilted swords seem to arise with the transition to leather gloves. Even with swords only sharp at the end, I wouldn't want to expose my hand like that out in front of the guard without a steel gauntlet.
    – DukeZhou
    Jul 9 at 23:51
  • The one legitimate use I see for half-swording with a basket hilt broadsword (arming sword) would be to penetrate the breastplate of foe lying prone or supine on the ground.
    – DukeZhou
    Jul 9 at 23:55
1

Half swording.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Half-sword

There is no space in a basket hilt to use two hands, so the second hand would be on the blade. It became more common with all swords as armour improved.

0
  • There is no way to wield a proper basket hilt sword two-handed.

This is because the enclosure of the basket shape is specifically designed to protect the sword hand by covering as much of the area around the and as possible.

When wielding two-handed, such as with a longsword, the forearms come in from different angles. The most coverage you could get would be 180 degrees to the front, if that, and it would still limit a range of potential techniques.

The only thing I've seen proposed is the two-handed Swiss saber,but I wouldn't categorize that limited hand guard as a basket hilt.

The fact that some Swiss sabers have such guards reinforces the vulnerability of the hands in combat with long blades, where the hands/wrists are usually the most accessible target at range.

The introduction of some form of hand protection may relate to transition from steel gauntlets to leather gloves around that general time period, but the design doesn't seem to have caught on, and the use of the Swiss saber was probably specialized.

The lack of steel gauntlets in the basket-hilt era would make half-swording too risky, and there's not much reason to do it with a single-handed sword.

See also: Are there any historical two-handed basket-hilt swords?

enter image description here

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.