3

I'm doing a little bit of research for a project.

Basically, for a fighting style that consists mostly of punches, what are the pros and cons of body-fitting pants (trousers, not overly tight skinny jeans etc), and those that are more on the baggy side (cargo pants, loose jeans and such)? Does this answer change if we introduce kicks and grabs?

As far as I know, footing is really important even in boxing, hence, this question.

  • 3
    I'm confused; if this is a tournament setting, follow the rules. If this is for everyday self defense, you fight with what you're wearing, you don't go home to change clothes. If your technique is so optimized that the style of your pants affects the speed and impact of your punches, then I don't think you need to fear anyone on earth. – Mark C. Wallace Jun 9 '18 at 12:45
  • It's an everyday self-defense thing. The question is "what do you choose to wear given all the options" - like, given a choice of "high heels" and "no heels", you choose the latter because high heels suck in fighting situations. I thought the style of pants can affect footing, which is why I asked the question here – Baka-Mastermind Jun 9 '18 at 14:23
3

Neither, you should be looking for something that does not restrict your move set.

If your main protagonist is wearing a tight t-shirt, then as soon as he throw a big punch, there's gonna be a ripping sound as the t-shirt shears a la Hulk. If they are wearing a tight fitting pencil skirt, any kicks is going to be impeded, the skirt will tear, and their underwear will show.

Other things to consider are things like keys in pockets as falling on them might cause injuries. Doing break falls with those in your trouser pockets is inadvisable unless the situation really demands it. Ditto with phones, chain-wallets, and other things attached to one's trousers.

You might want to browse no nonsense self defense as it is good source material.

| improve this answer | |
2

Body-fitting: The only possible pro I can see is jock support. But this is achieved in a number of ways with loose shorts as well, so it may not be very valid. The other reason for wearing body-fitting clothes is aerodynamic advantage (think swimming, cycling)- not much of a concern in martial arts.

Loose: The biggest pro is ventilation, which keeps body temperature in check and allows you to fight longer. Besides, it allows rapid stance changes much more than tight trousers would.

I don't foresee a change in case of kicks/grabs. Maybe in a street fight situation (not controlled sport), something baggy could get caught on nearby objects.

| improve this answer | |
  • another pro is compression. body fitting garments hold your muscle tight as a guard would do. important if you're over 40 – Kristina Lex Dec 28 '18 at 6:49

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.