Should I avoid open-handed blocks in sparring?

Question

I've been studying taekwondo for about 15 years, and I've always been taught to keep my fists closed tightly in sparring to reduce the chance of finger injury. Splayed fingers seems to be a common error, especially among younger students.

By the time a student receives their black belt, they've learned to keep their fists closed all the time. But a few years after that, once they start getting into the dan ranks, open-handed blocks always seem to creep back into their repertoire - I've noticed this in myself and plenty of other senior students. These aren't the splayed-finger disasters that junior students sometimes do - the thumb is tucked in, fingers are nice and tight.

My question is, should we still try to avoid open-handed techniques even once we've learned to make a decent knife-hand? Or are open-handed blocks safe, once you've developed enough experience?

Answer 1

I can give a Hapkido perspective on this, since at least at my dojang we are taught that you keep your fists closed until you reach 1 dan, at which point you can open them (and do so more and more as you go up from there). We relax it a bit for blocks (we don't teach hard blocks until 9th kup), but not for attacks.

There are two major reasons we give for emphasizing closed-fist technique in sparring:

1. It prevents an injury to yourself from a jammed finger or something similar.
2. It prevents you from injuring them.

In TKD there may be tournament reasons for keeping your fist closed which do not apply to HKD, but I can address these two reasons.

Injury to Self

From my perspective, once your technique gets into the dan range then it is both natural and desirable that you would open up your hands when doing the techniques where appropriate.

Assuming, of course, that your technique is good enough to justify it. Your training by that point should be good enough that the risk of injury to yourself is substantially reduced, and you can actually make a more nuanced decision about when it might be appropriate, and also are more prepared to deal with the consequences if you are wrong.

Injury to the Opponent

This mostly is involved in attacks. Here the problem is that many open handed techniques–especially if improperly aimed or if there is a mistake–can cause substantively greater damage than a fist is likely to do. It's one thing to miss a bit on a punch to the chest, it's another to screw up on something designed to hit their eyes. Especially in arts where head strikes and throws are banned, there's also less reason to employ open-handed attacks.

Here I think there is still merit in limiting your repertoire that your use while sparring.

Conclusion

With blocks, unless your instructor says otherwise, I'd say "go for it" since many of the safety concerns are obviated by the point that your technique has solidified a little. That said, I might have that conversation with your instructor, since he may have a set point where that becomes more allowable, or may feel that you personally aren't ready for it. On the other hand, he may also feel that now it is time to learn it and use it in a sparring context.

Answer 2

An open hand requires less tension, which means faster movements. Once you have acquired the awareness/control over your hand, and your fingers aren't all over the place, it is to your benefit to modulate the tension and change your hand's position. I know that when I spar, with closed hands, I feel like I have much fewer options available, and I feel like I'm losing sensitivity to what's happening around me.

Answer 3

Based on my training, open handed blocks are acceptable and even encouraged, but these may be different then what you are thinking of. We use an open hand to push the blow aside by striking the side of the incoming fist, the wrist, or the forearm. This is certainly something which requires having built up a sense of timing, but it can be quite effective. The potential for injury would probably be in a mistimed block which causes the open hand to be hit.

Answer 4

I am now studying TKD after many years of sparring open handed whilst learning Kung Fu. Tonight my sparring partner took exception to this non TKD technique. I obliged him with closed fist inner and outer blocks. I did not have the same level of control and of course this means striking bone against bone, rather than palm against bone. The consequence is that we are both now nursing sore arms and shins.

Answer 5

We teach knife-hand blocks for a reason. They're faster, require less energy and reduce the chance of a strike glancing off and hitting you anyway because the knife-hand block is more elastic than the closed fist variant. In other words, it remains in contact with the strike slightly longer than a more rigid closed-fist block. It also puts you in a more favourable position to perform a grab in one motion, if it is prudent.

Answer 6

One should have dramatically less confidence in techniques which have not been validated in sparring and, optimally, competition.

That said, striking sparring with open fingers leads to broken, sprained, and jammed fingers, as well as accidental eyepokes. You should evaluate your need for open-handed techniques accordingly.